[影片]My Boy Jack - Rudyard Kipling的个人悲剧

入得谷来,祸福自求。
Post Reply
CAVA
Posts: 8169
Joined: 2003-12-06 16:55

[影片]My Boy Jack - Rudyard Kipling的个人悲剧

Post by CAVA » 2007-11-12 12:57

Image

11月11日在英国是Remembrance Day,阵亡将士纪念日。对英国人来说,记忆中最惨痛的战争仍然是一战,刚进11月就有很多人配戴poppy花。

昨天电视播了舞台剧My Boy Jack的改编本。直到最近才知道Rudyard Kipling等于亲手把18岁的儿子送上了死亡之路。

[quote]It is said that every family in Britain was touched by the first world war but few could have felt its tragic sting more keenly than Rudyard Kipling. The author who entranced children with The Jungle Book and his Just So stories was also a fervent wartime propagandist whose intervention led his beloved teenage son, John, to die amid the carnage of the trenches. The decision tormented him for the rest of his life.

John Kipling’s death in France at the age of 18 was a metaphor for the blindness of a conflict in which a whole generation volunteered to fight against Germany. Chronically shortsighted, he was killed on his first day of action, unable to see a thing. In torrential rain, he could either have taken his glasses off and seen nothing, or kept them on with the same result. That day there were 7,500 casualties, rising to 50,000 by the end of the battle.

Two years later, after a futile crusade to locate his son’s body and give it a proper burial, Kipling wrote a powerful epitaph that became the universal voice of every teenager who had perished:

If any question why we died,
Tell them, because our fathers lied.


With the ear of the prime minister and of the king, Kipling had been a powerful advocate of the war and a recruiter who believed that in order to preserve the British Empire as a benign and essential force of world stability, an aggressive empire-building Germany should be stopped.

He had once proclaimed: “We must demand that every fit young man come forward to enlist and that every young man who chooses to remain at home be shunned by his community.”

His letters to John

Jun
Posts: 27816
Joined: 2003-12-15 11:43

Post by Jun » 2007-11-12 13:19

At least he was sincere in his belief in the grand ideal of the Empire and got what he asked for. Unlike most war hawks who send other people's children to be blown into pieces.
此喵已死,有事烧纸

森林的火焰
Posts: 2913
Joined: 2005-09-08 9:45
Contact:

Post by 森林的火焰 » 2007-11-12 13:35

人都有犯糊涂的时候,他能在儿子的墓上写那样两句话,倒真的说明他的勇和毅,而不是给自己找点“我不后悔“的理由。活生生的把自己做成反面教材。应该也有不少热血青年或者热血父亲读过以后,及时回头的吧。
我觉得,在巨大的丧子之痛里,不是找个藉口推托怪社会,或者充“英雄父亲“的形象继续装偶像,而是担起自己的那一部分战争责任,真是挺难得的。
http://harps.yculblog.com
搬家了搬家了

森林的火焰
Posts: 2913
Joined: 2005-09-08 9:45
Contact:

Post by 森林的火焰 » 2007-11-12 13:37

Black Adder第四季到最后,忽然变成了非喜剧。Black Adder在战壕边发表了一段很长的沉重的演说,然后钢琴响起,镜头模糊,然后就是一片开满poppy flower的原野。我简直不能置信结局竟然是这样的,大哭一场。
http://harps.yculblog.com
搬家了搬家了

火星狗
Posts: 3171
Joined: 2006-03-03 13:56

Post by 火星狗 » 2007-11-12 13:40

HP吗?

在那个时代,那种观念很可能是灌输给小孩的正统观念(现在有时候也是)。其实完全是国家机器的利益在作祟。

有些儿童作品本身就够吓人的,我以前被《水孩儿》给真正吓倒过一次。

CAVA
Posts: 8169
Joined: 2003-12-06 16:55

Post by CAVA » 2007-11-12 14:16

没错,HP,Daniel Radcliffe。

用现在的标准看,吉卜林是彻头彻尾的帝国主义分子,他不是被灌输者,而是积极的鼓吹者。

巨大天真的热情或早或迟被战壕里的严酷现实摧毁了,所以1920那一代的精神迷失特别彻底吧。

火星狗
Posts: 3171
Joined: 2006-03-03 13:56

Post by 火星狗 » 2007-11-12 15:58

积极的鼓吹者要么特别不信那一套,纯粹是摆pose,要么是真诚的相信曾经被灌输的理念。吉卜林显然是后者,不然他会把自己的儿子藏的好好的。

HP同学好像很适合角色。其实我想说的是,这张剧照真好,一个表情胜过千言万语。

Blackadder最后给我印象最深的是达令的穷途末路。一方面他那pose好像被大魔王迫害的少女,滑稽的要命,另一方面那情节真是惊得我起了鸡皮疙瘩。达令看不起Blackadder,固然是个性冲突,还有一个原因是Blackadder是前线的消耗品,一颗流弹过来也许就没命,而达令舒舒服服呆在后方的司令部里,生命安全有保障,他简直没法不感到superior。他哪会想到有一天头头会满面春风的随手把他丢到门外,和Blackadder一起面对无意义的死亡。达令并不是天真可爱的George,人家说什么George就信什么。从某种意义上讲达令和blackadder是知己。两个人完全都明白战争是怎么回事,而且两个人的努力方向完全一致,在这场荒谬的战争中保住小命。达令肯定认为自己已经上岸了,没想到一下子直接给扔回河中心。他哆嗦成那个样子,是因为他完全明白之后等待他的是什么。就算他是个猥琐可笑的小男人,也不deserve这样的结局,事实上任何人都不应该这样死。
Last edited by 火星狗 on 2007-11-12 16:18, edited 2 times in total.

Jun
Posts: 27816
Joined: 2003-12-15 11:43

Post by Jun » 2007-11-12 16:08

Kipling 那样的热烈patriotic 的调调儿在大英帝国的全盛时期实在是太普遍了,太典型了。普天之下莫为王土嘛。讽刺英帝国的如毛姆,揭露反对的如Joseph Conrad,都不是“纯英国人”。
此喵已死,有事烧纸

豪情
Posts: 21256
Joined: 2003-11-22 18:47

Post by 豪情 » 2007-11-12 16:41

今天在美国好象也算个节(老兵节), 据说很多地方放假, 原来和一战有关?但这和美国有什么大关系, 没看见纪念二战的节. MEMORIAL DAY又怎么来的?

Jun
Posts: 27816
Joined: 2003-12-15 11:43

Post by Jun » 2007-11-12 16:42

美国也加入过一战的呀,所以公用“退伍军人节”,Memorial Day是阵亡军人纪念日。
此喵已死,有事烧纸

豪情
Posts: 21256
Joined: 2003-11-22 18:47

Post by 豪情 » 2007-11-12 17:13

是加入了但是好象没伤筋动骨啊, 比起后来的二战韩战越战伊拉克的投入和损失都小吧. 当然一战是美国崛起的基础.

森林的火焰
Posts: 2913
Joined: 2005-09-08 9:45
Contact:

Post by 森林的火焰 » 2007-11-12 17:21

火星狗不提我简直都要想不起来亲爱的达令上尉了。当然最让我难过的是George的死。他总是一个那么天真可爱的瘦长脸。所以多年后他突然变身为世故讽剌的Dr.House出现的时候,我悲喜交集地在大海报前站了五分钟不肯走。
http://harps.yculblog.com
搬家了搬家了

CAVA
Posts: 8169
Joined: 2003-12-06 16:55

Post by CAVA » 2007-11-13 2:40

火星你真厉害,I've never given Darling a thought really,现在细想想,这个人物设置的确不是可有可无的。

英国现任财务大臣名叫Alistair Darling,新闻里一报到他的名字我就想笑。

Post Reply